1HR and People Management1 punt

Explain the difference between HR and People Management. Give an example. Which strategic question replaces "How many people do we need?"

Solució

Model answer

HR is the function that designs the practices and processes to attract, develop, manage, motivate and retain employees. People Management is how leaders use those processes to manage people effectively. For example, HR designs the recruitment process, and a manager interviews the candidates, selects the most suitable one and integrates the person into the team.

The strategic question is: "What capabilities will we need to compete successfully in the future?" The role of the People Manager pivots around two axes: taking care of people and taking care of the business.

Idees clau: HR dissenya, els caps apliquen · exemple de selecció · capacitats, no nombre de persones · dos eixos.

2The system, not only the person1,5 punts

A company wants to compete through innovation. It hires highly qualified engineers and creates an innovation department. Managers reject ideas that might fail, each decision needs several approvals and departments rarely share information. After two years, management says: "Our employees are not innovative enough." Do you agree? Justify your answer.

Solució

Model answer

I do not agree. The problem is probably not a lack of talent: the company has hired qualified engineers. The problem is the organisational environment in which the talent works. Managers punish failure, decisions need several layers of approval and information is not shared. These structures, leadership behaviours, incentives and processes constrain people's capabilities.

The principle is that people performance is not simply an individual characteristic; it is influenced by the system in which people work. Individual capability is what people know and can do. Organisational capability is what the organisation accomplishes by combining people, structure, technology, processes and leadership. Here the individual capability exists, but the organisational capability to innovate does not.

Before any decision about people, I would diagnose the system: how many ideas are rejected and why, how long an approval takes, and what behaviour is rewarded.

Idees clau: el talent hi és · el sistema el frena · frase del principi · capacitat individual vs organitzativa · diagnòstic abans de decidir.

3The alignment chain1,25 punts
  1. Write the alignment chain between business strategy and people strategy.
  2. Is there a "best" people strategy for all companies? Compare international expansion and operational efficiency.
Solució

Model answer

  1. Business strategy → strategic priorities → required organisational capabilities → people capabilities → People Management strategy (HR).
  2. No. There is no universally best people strategy. Its relevance depends on what the organisation is trying to achieve. A company that pursues international expansion needs international leadership, cultural intelligence, mobility, knowledge of local labour markets, succession planning and coordination of dispersed teams. A company that pursues operational efficiency needs process expertise, workforce planning, productivity, automation, performance management and a cost-effective organisational design.

Strategic alignment is the consistency between business strategy, organisational capabilities and people management decisions. If the people strategy is disconnected from the business strategy, the company recruits and trains for the wrong capabilities.

Idees clau: els cinc passos de la cadena · «no universally best» · dues llistes de prioritats · definició d'alineament.

4Four concepts1 punt

Classify each sentence as culture, climate, structure or design, and justify it:

  1. "Here we have always rewarded people who never make a mistake."
  2. "Since the relocation was announced, the team is anxious."
  3. "Logistics reports to the operations director."
  4. "Discounts above 10% are decided by the area manager."
Solució

Model answer

  1. Organisational culture: a shared and stable pattern of what is rewarded.
  2. Organisational climate: how employees currently perceive their working environment. It can change fast.
  3. Organisational structure: a formal reporting relationship (the organisation chart).
  4. Organisational design: how authority and decisions are divided and coordinated.

Idees clau: cultura = estable, què es premia · clima = ara · estructura = organigrama · disseny = qui decideix què.

5Diagnose before you act1,5 punts

A restaurant chain has 40% annual turnover. Management wants to raise all salaries by 10%. You know that turnover is much higher in 3 of the 12 restaurants, that 60% of exits happen in the first three months and that those 3 restaurants have overtime every week.

  1. Why can the salary increase be a mistake?
  2. Propose three hypotheses with their evidence and intervention.
Solució

Model answer

  1. It is a solution before the diagnosis. The data points to local causes and to the start of the employment relationship, not to a general pay problem. The principle is evidence before solution: first understand what is happening, why it is happening and what evidence supports the explanation.

HypothesisEvidenceIntervention
Management qualityTurnover is concentrated in 3 restaurantsAssess and train those managers
WorkloadWeekly overtime in the same restaurantsResize shifts and staffing
Recruitment or onboarding60% leave in the first three monthsReview the profile and create an onboarding plan

Pay is still a possible cause. To test it, I would compare salaries with the local market and read the exit interviews.

Idees clau: solució sense diagnòstic · «evidence before solution» · tres hipòtesis, cadascuna amb evidència i intervenció.

6Global-Tech2 punts

Global-Tech is a 500-person software company. In six months, new customer acquisition is down 18%, churn has risen from 7% to 11% and two senior managers have resigned. The CEO says people have lost motivation. The HR director wants to replace underperformers. Team members say: "Nobody knows who has the final decision" and "We are measured on revenue, but we don't control pricing, product priorities or implementation capacity." Sales says marketing sends poor-quality leads. Product says Growth keeps changing priorities.

  1. Use the four dimensions of organisational diagnosis.
  2. Write your preliminary diagnosis.
  3. Recommend three actions.
Solució

Model answer

  1. Four dimensions:
DimensionEvidencePossible root cause
StructureNobody knows who decides. Revenue targets without controlUnclear decision rights. Responsibility without authority
TalentTwo senior managers resigned. No evidence of missing capabilitiesLoss of knowledge; probably a consequence
ClimateLower engagement and motivationFrustration with the system: a symptom
ProcessesPoor leads, priorities change every few weeks, slow launchesNo shared prioritisation between departments
  1. Preliminary diagnosis: the main problem is structure and processes, evidenced by the unclear decision rights and the conflict between Sales, Marketing, Growth and Product. Low motivation and the resignations are probably consequences, not the root cause. The CEO and the HR director propose solutions before the evidence.

  2. Actions: (a) Structural: define who decides what and give the Growth Team authority over the levers of its targets. (b) Talent: exit interviews with the senior managers and retention of critical roles; no dismissals before the diagnosis. (c) Process: one quarterly prioritisation shared by the four departments, with an agreed definition of a good lead.

Before any major decision I would ask for one piece of evidence: where the work slows down, for example the time each decision takes.

Idees clau: STCP · la motivació és un símptoma · «responsibility without authority» · una acció estructural, una de talent i una de procés.

7VRIO1 punt

A bookshop chain has: (1) a loyalty programme like most shops; (2) booksellers with 20 years of experience who recommend books from memory, in a culture that gives them time and autonomy; (3) a new online recommendation system that no competitor has yet, but which can be bought from a supplier; (4) a unique database of customer tastes that nobody uses. Apply VRIO to each resource.

Solució

Model answer

VRIO asks four questions in order: is the resource valuable, rare, inimitable and is the company organised to exploit it?

  1. Valuable but not rare → competitive parity.
  2. Valuable, rare, hard to imitate (years of culture) and organised (time and autonomy) → sustainable competitive advantage.
  3. Valuable and rare, but imitable (competitors can buy it) → temporary advantage.
  4. Valuable, rare and hard to imitate, but not organised → unused advantage.

Idees clau: les quatre preguntes en ordre · el primer «no» dona el resultat · les capacitats basades en persones i cultura són les més difícils de copiar.

8People, culture, productivity, results0,75 punts

A company increased its training budget by 20%. Engagement fell from 82% to 68%, voluntary turnover rose from 8% to 17%, product-development time rose from 9 to 13 months and customer satisfaction fell from 88% to 79%. Revenue per employee rose 5%. Management says: "Our people are highly skilled, so people cannot be the problem." Comment.

Solució

Model answer

Skilled people do not guarantee results. The chain is people → culture → productivity → results. The human capital is strong, but the fall in engagement and the higher voluntary turnover suggest a cultural problem: for example leadership, recognition, autonomy or how mistakes are treated. Culture then affects productivity (development is four months slower) and results (customers are less satisfied). The 5% increase in revenue per employee does not compensate four negative indicators and will probably not last.

I would recommend a diagnosis of culture and climate (survey, exit interviews, decision processes) before more training.

Idees clau: la cadena de quatre baules · el problema és la cultura, no la qualificació · un indicador bo no compensa quatre de dolents.